Jul 9
Best dogs for NYC living
So, I’ve stumbled across a few articles that claim to list the breeds of dogs that are best suited for life in New York City, but I can’t say that I agree with their choices. First of all, neither list includes the Brussels Griffon (unfortunate oversight, I’m sure).
The Nouveau Native recommends only dogs that are small or medium sized (yet not the Brussels?!?), but I think they are missing out on some great large breed dogs - the giant breeds that tend to be more sedentary (Bernese, Greater Swiss Mountain Dogs, Newfoundlands, St. Bernards, etc.) seem to do very well in an urban environment. Although it may not be completely intuitive to have a large breed dog in an apartment, these dogs need far less exercise than labs, goldens or other Sporting or Herding breeds. The laid back personalities of these large breeds also make them ideal for an environment where they are likely to be exposed to many other dogs and people.
The New York Magazinehad a much more diverse selection of recommended breeds in terms of size and I love that adopting a mixed breed dog was #1, but Greyhounds, Labradors & Portuguese Water Dogs?? Really?? Those dogs need a ton of exercise…I’m not saying that these breeds shouldn’t live in NYC, but the owner really needs to be dedicated to making sure that these breeds get the exercise that they need. I can’t tell you how many neurotic labs and goldens we see in the dog run and I’m convinced that it’s because they just aren’t getting the exercise that they need. The good news is that there are now services like dog running to help busy owners keep their pets healthy and happy.
So, there you have my non-expert opinion. What do you think are the best dog breeds for NYC living?
3 Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
I’m a Running Paws customer! In fact when the NYT did an article last year they used me and my buddy Louie the Weimeraner as models.
But you’re quite correct that certain breeds need lots of exercise to make good city dogs. I believe if you’re willing to dedicate your life completely to your dog, any breed can be an apt. dog.
Wimsey
Comment by Wimsey — July 9, 2008 @ 6:27 pm
We are not NYers but have had 2 Brussels-Griffons for the last 14 years. We both work during the day. Our BG’s are perfectly content to “guard” the house until we return. They are loving pets with expressive faces that melt our hearts daily. We crate them overnight which supplies them a zone of safety. BG’s definitely get our vote! Great dogs, super pets, loving companions.
Comment by Dewey Diva — July 10, 2008 @ 7:55 am
As the proud owner of 2 PWD’s (Portuguese Water Dogs), I would highly recommend that unless you’re retired or have a pretty loose schedule, that you not own one in the city. These dogs are VERY smart and VERY high energy! Like if they are not exercised they will get into trouble. We live in the country and my wonderful husband walks them for 2-3 miles, twice each day, in the woods and around the neighborhood AND they have a good 20-30 minutes of ball chasing AND they get to roam and run in the big yard for hours per day and they still keep on going….they’re sweet, smart dogs but please pass if you don’t have the time/space.
Comment by Min — July 11, 2008 @ 6:47 am